Nutritional Breakdown by Food Type: Fresh, Raw, and Kibble Diets

Below is a comparison of Fresh, Raw, and Kibble diets based on how they meet AAFCO nutrient requirements for dogs. Each section discusses protein, fats, carbohydrates, vitamins, minerals, water content, and gastrointestinal health.

  1. Fresh Diets

Fresh diets include home-cooked meals or commercially prepared fresh food delivered or purchased frozen/refrigerated.

πŸ₯© Protein

      • Typically high-quality animal protein (e.g., chicken, beef, turkey, fish).
      • Protein digestibility is generally high due to gentle cooking methods.
      • Must be balanced with proper amino acids to meet AAFCO standards.

⚠️ Risks: Improperly balanced home-cooked diets may lack essential amino acids like taurine or lysine.

πŸ«’ Fats

      • Often sourced from animal fats (chicken fat, fish oil) and plant oils (coconut, flaxseed).
      • Rich in Omega-3 (ALA, EPA, DHA) and Omega-6 (linoleic acid).
      • Typically meets or exceeds AAFCO requirements.

⚠️ Risks: Imbalances in fat ratios can lead to skin/coat issues or inflammation.

🍚 Carbohydrates

      • Often include vegetables (e.g., sweet potatoes, carrots) and grains (e.g., brown rice, quinoa).
      • Provide fiber for digestion and energy.

⚠️ Risks: Excessive carbohydrates can lead to obesity if not balanced with activity levels.

πŸ’Š Vitamins & Minerals

      • Often derived from whole food sources (e.g., liver, leafy greens).
      • Commercial fresh diets typically include vitamin and mineral supplements to meet AAFCO guidelines.

⚠️ Risks: Home-cooked diets risk nutritional deficiencies without proper supplementation.

πŸ’§ Water Content

      • Fresh diets are moisture-rich (approx. 70–80% water).
      • Helps maintain hydration and kidney health.

🦠 Gastrointestinal Health

      • Highly digestible due to whole, lightly cooked ingredients.
      • Supports a healthy gut microbiome.
      • Often recommended for dogs with sensitive stomachs or digestive issues.

βœ… Best For: Owners who can commit to research, preparation, or high-quality commercial fresh diets.

  1. Raw Diets

Raw diets include commercially prepared raw meals or homemade raw feeding (e.g., BARF or Prey Model Raw).

πŸ₯© Protein

      • Extremely high in animal protein (meat, organs, bones).
      • Typically high digestibility and complete amino acid profile when varied protein sources are included.

⚠️ Risks: Incomplete amino acid profiles if diet lacks variety.

πŸ«’ Fats

      • Naturally occurring animal fats and omega-rich oils (e.g., fish oil).
      • Balanced fats contribute to healthy skin and coat condition.

⚠️ Risks: Excessive fat intake can cause pancreatitis in predisposed dogs.

🍚 Carbohydrates

      • Limited or absent in prey-model diets.
      • Some BARF diets include small amounts of fruits and vegetables.

⚠️ Risks: Lack of carbohydrates can reduce prebiotic fiber, potentially affecting gut health.

πŸ’Š Vitamins & Minerals

      • Derived from organ meats, bones, and vegetables.
      • Calcium-to-phosphorus ratio must be carefully balanced.
      • Commercial raw diets typically add vitamin supplements to ensure AAFCO compliance.

⚠️ Risks: Homemade raw diets often lack proper vitamin D, zinc, or manganese.

πŸ’§ Water Content

      • Raw diets have high moisture content (approx. 65–75% water).
      • Supports hydration and kidney function.

🦠 Gastrointestinal Health

      • Raw diets are highly digestible for many dogs.
      • May improve stool consistency and reduce stool volume.
      • Probiotics from raw meat may benefit gut health.

⚠️ Risks: Raw diets carry a bacterial contamination risk (e.g., Salmonella, E. coli). Proper handling and sourcing are critical.

βœ… Best For: Owners committed to education, proper food safety practices, and sourcing high-quality raw ingredients.

  1. Kibble Diets

Kibble is the most common commercial dog food, formulated to meet AAFCO standards.

πŸ₯© Protein

      • Derived from meat meals (e.g., chicken meal, fish meal) and sometimes plant protein (e.g., peas, soy).
      • Highly processed, which may reduce protein bioavailability.

⚠️ Risks: Lower-quality kibble may use fillers and low-quality protein sources.

πŸ«’ Fats

      • Often sourced from chicken fat, fish oil, flaxseed oil.
      • Added to meet Omega-3 and Omega-6 requirements.

⚠️ Risks: Poor-quality fats can become rancid if improperly stored.

🍚 Carbohydrates

      • Carbs form the bulk of most kibble formulas.
      • Sources include corn, rice, wheat, barley, or legumes.
      • Provide energy and fiber.

⚠️ Risks: Excessive carbohydrates in low-quality kibble can contribute to obesity and insulin resistance.

πŸ’Š Vitamins & Minerals

      • Synthetic vitamins and minerals are often added post-cooking to meet AAFCO standards.
      • Fortification compensates for nutrient loss during high-heat processing.

⚠️ Risks: Over-reliance on synthetic nutrients can reduce bioavailability.

πŸ’§ Water Content

      • Very low moisture content (approx. 10–12% water).
      • Dogs must drink more water when consuming kibble.

⚠️ Risks: Dehydration risk in dogs who don’t drink enough water.

🦠 Gastrointestinal Health

      • Generally well-tolerated, but some dogs may struggle with digestibility due to high carbohydrate content and processing.
      • May cause gastric upset in sensitive dogs.

βœ… Best For: Busy owners needing convenient, cost-effective food with consistent nutrient profiles.

Comparison Table

NutrientFreshRawKibble
ProteinHigh, digestibleVery high, digestibleModerate-high, variable quality
FatsBalancedBalancedAdded fats
CarbsModerateLowHigh
VitaminsNatural + addedNatural + addedSynthetic
WaterHigh (70–80%)High (65–75%)Low (10–12%)
DigestibilityHighHighModerate
ConvenienceModerateLowHigh

 

Skip to content